What's in Amazon's 100 best-selling sunscreens
We read every label. More than half of them are the same four chemicals.
By Kevin Gianni, co-founder of Salt+Blue. Labels read November 20, 2026.
I'm a sucker for the front of a bottle. What's the SPF? Is it waterproof? Does it have a little green leaf on it that's supposed to mean it's natural? I've spent more than twenty years reading ingredient labels, and the leaf still gets me.
The back of the bottle is where they have to tell you what's in it. Hardly anybody reads it, so we did โ for all 100 of the best-selling sunscreens on Amazon.
I think we put too many chemicals on our skin, and I want fewer of them on mine. It's why we started Salt+Blue, and it's why we make a mineral sunscreen. So no, I'm not neutral. But I didn't write these labels. The brands did.
The short version
- 65 of the 97 sunscreens we could confirm are chemical only. 25 are mineral only. 7 use both.
- 54 of the 97 list the same four active ingredients: avobenzone, homosalate, octisalate and octocrylene.
- 72 of the 97 contain at least one filter the FDA says it needs more safety data on.
- 12 of the 25 mineral-only sunscreens contain butyloctyl salicylate, a UV absorber listed as an inactive ingredient.
- Oxybenzone is on 1 label today. The FDA has an oxybenzone version on file for 20 more of the best-sellers.
What we did
On November 20, 2026, we pulled Amazon's list of the 100 best-selling sunscreens in the US and read the ingredients on every one. Then we checked each against the label its maker filed with the FDA. Sunscreen is regulated as an over-the-counter drug here, so every formula has paperwork, and the paperwork is public.2
We could confirm the formula on 97 of the 100. (The other three didn't show their active ingredients on the listing and had no label on file under their name.) We're not naming brands. The story here is the whole shelf.
Twenty-seven brands, four ingredients
I expected more variety.
Two out of three of these sunscreens โ 65 of the 97 โ are chemical only. Twenty-five are mineral only (zinc oxide, titanium dioxide, or both), and seven mix the two.
And the chemical ones are, more or less, the same sunscreen. Fifty-four of the 97 list the exact same four active ingredients: avobenzone, homosalate, octisalate and octocrylene. Those 54 come from 27 different brands. They're lotions, serums, sticks, lip balms and every single one of the seven sprays on the list, and they run from SPF 25 to SPF 100. Different bottle, different leaf, same four chemicals. Grab a best-seller at random and the odds are better than even that's what you're rubbing in.
Share of the 97 products that list each active ingredient
| Octisalate | 66 (68%) | |
| Avobenzone | 64 (66%) | |
| Homosalate | 63 (65%) | |
| Octocrylene | 60 (62%) | |
| Zinc oxide | 30 (31%) | |
| Titanium dioxide | 15 (15%) | |
| Octinoxate | 10 (10%) | |
| Oxybenzone | 1 (1%) | |
| Meradimate | 1 (1%) | |
| Bemotrizinol | 1 (1%) |
Amazon US Best Sellers in Sunscreens, ranks 1 to 100, captured November 20, 2026. Source: Salt+Blue label audit.
Zinc oxide, for comparison, is in 30.
Even the FDA won't vouch for them
I don't put a lot of stock in the FDA. It's a slow, bloated agency, and the pharmaceutical and chemical companies it's supposed to be watching have a lot of pull over what it does. So I'm not bringing it up as the last word on anything. I'm bringing it up because when even the FDA won't sign off on an ingredient, that should get your attention.
In 2021 the agency proposed new sunscreen rules, and in them it named exactly two filters it had enough data on to call safe and effective: zinc oxide and titanium dioxide. For 12 others it said it needs more safety data. All four of the ingredients above are on that list of 12.5 Five years later, as of September 2026, the proposal still isn't final,5 and 72 of the 97 best-sellers contain at least one of the 12. That's every chemical sunscreen on the list.
The agency's own scientists have also tested what happens after you put this stuff on. In a 2020 study, they had 48 people apply sunscreen and then tested their blood. All six chemical filters in the study โ these same four, plus oxybenzone and octinoxate โ showed up in the bloodstream above the level where the FDA says an ingredient needs more safety testing. That was after one application, on the first day.7
The people who ran that study were careful to say it's no reason to stop wearing sunscreen, and nobody has shown that these chemicals hurt you once they're in your blood. Nobody has shown that they don't, either. That's what "we need more data" means, and it's been the answer for five years.
I don't eat sunscreen, and I'd rather not have it in my bloodstream. Until somebody can tell me what it's doing in there, I'll stick with the two filters that aren't on that list.
The "inactive" ingredient that absorbs UV
This is the one that bothers me most, because it catches the people who are trying to do what I'm trying to do.
If you buy mineral sunscreen, you're probably doing it to get away from chemical UV filters. So we read past the active ingredients on the 25 mineral-only sunscreens and went through the inactive list.
Twelve of the 25 contain butyloctyl salicylate. It's a salicylate โ the same chemical family as octisalate and homosalate โ and it absorbs UV. When a Journal of Cosmetic Science study tested sunscreen solvents on their own, butyloctyl salicylate came back with a lab-measured (in vitro) SPF of 19.5. Homosalate and octisalate, which are official sunscreen filters, were tested the same way and came back at 13.7 and 12.7.1
But butyloctyl salicylate isn't on the government's list of sunscreen active ingredients,4 so the label gets to file it under inactive. A bottle can say 100% mineral on the front and have a chemical UV absorber on the back that out-scored two real filters in that study.
I can't tell you how much it adds to the SPF of any of these 12. The study tested the ingredient alone, in a lab, and labels don't give the amount. And mineral brands aren't any worse about it than the rest: it's in about half of the other sunscreens too (35 of 72). But nobody buys a chemical sunscreen to avoid chemicals.
It should be on the front of the bottle. (Ours doesn't have it.)
Where did the oxybenzone go?
Oxybenzone is the sunscreen chemical most people have heard of. Hawaii banned the sale of sunscreens containing it, and octinoxate, starting in 2021, after its legislature found that both damage the state's marine life, coral reefs included.6
On Amazon's list today, oxybenzone is on exactly one label โ a lip balm. (Octinoxate is still in 10.)
So we went looking for where it went. The FDA keeps old labels on file, and the files say at least 20 more of today's best-sellers have had an oxybenzone version: same brand, same product line, same SPF, same form. Sixteen of those labels have dropped out of the FDA's directory of current products. Four haven't. For those four, the FDA has two current formulas on file under one product name, one with oxybenzone and one without. (Amazon was showing the one without, all four times.)
The records don't say why any of them changed. My read is that people stopped wanting it, a state made it illegal, and the formulas moved. I'll take that as good news. It means these companies can change what's in the bottle when enough of us decide we don't want it there.
But look at what's still in the bottle. Avobenzone, homosalate, octisalate, octocrylene โ all four are on the same needs-more-data list that oxybenzone is on.5
And if you've been buying the same sunscreen for years, it may not be the same sunscreen anymore. Don't just trust me. Check the back of the bottle and see for yourself.
Turn the bottle over
Wear sunscreen. I do, and nothing on this page is a reason not to. But pick it from the back of the bottle. The Drug Facts panel lists the active ingredients at the top and the inactive ones near the bottom. If you want fewer chemicals on your skin, look for zinc oxide or titanium dioxide up top and nothing else โ then read all the way down for butyloctyl salicylate, because nobody is going to put that on the front for you.
We make one that passes that test, so weigh everything above accordingly. Salt+Blue's only active ingredient is non-nano zinc oxide, there's no butyloctyl salicylate in it, and none of our products is on this list. The numbers, the method and the limits are all below. Feel free to check our work, and let us know if you find anything different. I'd love to hear about it.
Our mission is to make sure people, just like you, are informed so you can make the best possible decision for yourselves and your families.
The numbers
| Active ingredients | Products | Share of 97 |
|---|---|---|
| Chemical filters only | 65 | 67% |
| Mineral filters only (zinc oxide, titanium dioxide) | 25 | 26% |
| Both mineral and chemical | 7 | 7% |
Of the 25 mineral-only products, 11 use zinc oxide alone, 1 uses titanium dioxide alone and 13 use both. One product on the list is filed in two formulas by shade: its tinted shades add homosalate.
| Form (all 100) | Products | Filters |
|---|---|---|
| Lotion, cream, gel or serum | 78 | 47 chemical, 21 mineral, 7 both, 3 not confirmed |
| Lip balm | 8 | 7 chemical, 1 mineral |
| Spray | 7 | 7 chemical |
| Stick | 7 | 4 chemical, 3 mineral |
| SPF in the product title (all 100) | Products |
|---|---|
| Under 30 | 3 |
| 30 to 49 | 31 |
| 50 to 69 | 57 |
| 70 and up | 9 |
How we did it
- The list is Amazon US Best Sellers in Sunscreens, ranks 1 to 100, captured November 20, 2026 at 17:37 UTC.
- For each product we read the ingredient and active-ingredient fields on its Amazon page the same day.
- We pulled each maker's FDA label through openFDA2 and matched it to FDA's National Drug Code directory, which holds products with a current listing. That step separates a current formula from an old label still on file.
- A listing was matched to an FDA record on the product name, the form and the active ingredients, to the percentage where the listing gave percentages.
- A second, independent pass then re-read all 100 listings and their FDA records from scratch. It found an FDA record the first pass had missed, which moved one product from not confirmed to confirmed. It found no error in any other active ingredient, filter type or butyloctyl salicylate value. Twenty products had been matched to a sibling FDA record with the same active ingredients, such as another size, shade or flavor, and those matches were corrected.
- For the count of older oxybenzone formulas, we pulled every label in openFDA that names oxybenzone, 4,474 on the capture date, and matched them to the 97 products on brand, product line, SPF and form. Two of the labels name only the brand and SPF, and we matched those on form from the label's directions. Two more are filed under an earlier name for the same line. Each matching label was then checked against the National Drug Code directory to see whether it is a current listing. A second, independent pass then redid this count from FDA's label files without seeing the first result. It returned the same 21 products. FDA's public data keeps only the latest version of each label file, so a formula replaced inside the same file does not show up here.
| How the formula was confirmed | Products |
|---|---|
| Listing and a current FDA record agree | 82 |
| FDA record under the product's name; listing showed some or none of the active ingredients | 10 |
| Listing and an FDA label agree; label not in the current directory | 4 |
| Listing only; no FDA label found | 1 |
| Not confirmed | 3 |
Limits
- This is one retailer on one day, in Amazon's Black Friday week. November's list leans toward daily face products: 46 of the 100 have face or facial in the name, 8 are lip balms with SPF and 7 are sprays.
- We read labels. We did not test any product.
- A listing shows one formula. Where FDA has two on file, we counted the one on the listing.
- The Amazon best-seller ranking changes often. A capture on another day will hold different products.
We will repeat the audit in April 2027 from a new capture of the list.
Get the data
This page gives totals only. Journalists and researchers can ask for the per-product file, with each product's listing, FDA record and ingredients, through our contact page.
References
- Abou-Dahech M, Schaefer A, Lam-Phaure L, Huynh AN, Chandler M, Baki G. "Effect of Solvents on the In Vitro Sun Protection Factor and Broad-Spectrum Protection of Three Organic UV Filters." Journal of Cosmetic Science, vol. 71, no. 3 (2020), from p. 149. library.scconline.org/v071n03/44
- openFDA, Drug Labeling Overview. open.fda.gov/apis/drug/label
- FDA, final order OTC000039 amending OTC Monograph M020, Federal Register, June 10, 2026. federalregister.gov
- FDA, Over-the-Counter Monograph M020: Sunscreen Drug Products for Over-the-Counter Human Use, section M020.10, Sunscreen active ingredients. FDA monograph (PDF); later orders are listed on FDA's sunscreen regulatory actions page.
- FDA, proposed order OTC000008 (September 24, 2021), summarized in "Sunscreen: Highlights of FDA's Proposals." fda.gov/media/153965. Status of the proposal as of September 10, 2026: FDA's sunscreen regulatory actions page.
- Hawaii Revised Statutes ยง342D-21, Sale and distribution of sunscreen containing oxybenzone or octinoxate, or both; prohibition. data.capitol.hawaii.gov. Legislative findings: Act 104, Session Laws of Hawaii 2018.
- Matta MK, et al. "Effect of Sunscreen Application on Plasma Concentration of Sunscreen Active Ingredients: A Randomized Clinical Trial." JAMA, 2020;323(3):256-267. jamanetwork.com